Basil Garlic Colby Cheese

From a small Amish farm in Clare Michigan. Natural Way Cheese creates their artisan cheeses using a low-heat vat pastuerization, which takes longer, but results in a more flavorful cheese that retains beneficial enzymes while still killing off anything...

Black Bommer Cheddar 7oz Wheel

The award-winning Black Bommer is a modern classic. Marrying a delicious rich flavor with a smooth creaminess, our flagship cheddar cheese lasts long on the palate remains demandingly moreish. Black Bommer has won awards at The British Cheese Awards,...

Menage Cheese

This mixed-milk beauty is aged for intense flavor and a drier texture. It's dipped in a lovely wax as vibrant and green as Wisconsin's summertime pastures.

Vanilla Ice Cream

Half gallon

Chocolate Ice Cream

The Farmer’s Creamery is Michigan’s new favorite dairy and farm kitchen destination. Owned and operated by local Amish in the Mio area, they offer a full range of dairy items from 100% grass-fed cows, without antibiotics and no added hormones.

Toffee Crunch Ice Cream Bar

Vanilla wafers topped with creamy vanilla ice cream, covered in semi-sweet chocolate, a mound of toffee bits and drizzled with milk chocolate

Summertime S’mores Ice Cream Bar

Toasted marshmallow ice cream over a graham cracker crust, semi sweet chocolate coating, topped with toasted mini marshmallows

Green Dragon Ice Cream Bar

OREO  and BUTTERFINGER  cookie layer, mint chocolate chip ice cream, semi sweet chocolate, topped with OREO pieces and BUTTERFINGER crumbs

German Chocolate Cake Ice Cream Bar

Pecans and coconut icing layer topped with chocolate ice cream, semi-sweet chocolate and toasted coconut and pecans

Fancy Pants Raspberry Ice Cream Bar

Vanilla ice cream and raspberries are layered over a graham cracker crust and coated in a rich dark chocolate and sprinkled with coarse sea salt

Strawberry Lemonade Ice Cream Bar

Shortbread cookie layer, strawberry-lemon ice cream, white chocolate dip

Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Bar

Graham cracker crust filled with key lime ice cream dipped in white chocolate and topped with a drizzle of green chocolate

Caramel Cashewlicious Ice Cream Bar

Pretzel and caramel layer, vanilla ice cream, semi-sweet chocolate, and cashews

Salted Butter

8oz container of pasteurized sweet cream salted butter. No antibiotics, no added hormones!

Oat-ly Oat Milk Barista Edition

Oatly Barista Edition Oat Milk isn’t like other oat milk. This one has a Swedish pedigree. It was conceived, concocted, and packaged with a single purpose in mind: to ease the heartbreak of baristas everywhere. On top of its sterling performance under...

Califia Oat Milk Barista Blend

Upgrade your latte. Oat Barista Blend froths, foams, and steams perfectly for all your espresso creations. Or simply stir into hot or iced coffee, it blends beautifully without dairy, soy, or gluten. Just smooth and creamy plant-based goodness.

Cheese Colby

Colby, similar to Cheddar, does not undergo the cheddaring process. This soft, moist and fairly mild Colby is excellent as a table cheese, perfect for grating and grilling, and in snacks and salads. 8 ounces.

Cheese Marble

An outstanding mix of Colby and Michigan Jack cheeses. With wonderful color this cheese is terrific for cooking and is a delightful snacking cheese. 8 ounces.

Cheese Jack Michigan

This young Jack cheese is a deliciously mild cheese. Its creamy texture, high moisture and mild flavor make it easy to pair with fruits and a delicious compliment to any sandwich or burger. 8 ounces.

Cheese Dill

We cannot think of many combinations more perfect than dill and this supple Jack cheese. The creamy mild Jack has a slight buttery aroma and is given a subtle pop of flavor by the addition of fresh farm grown dill. This sweet and mellow cheese matches...

Cheese Olive

Olive cheese,  8 ounces

Greek Style Feta

ORO Cheese has a fermentation period  of 45 days. During that time, it changes the taste. It becomes deeper so you can feel the natural taste of milk. Each cheese here is specific and made with love. GREEK – firm, tangy and sharp white cheese – great for...

Burrata Mozzarella Domestic

We developed our Burrata authentically with a recipe that dates back over 5 generations. Our semi soft "Pasta Filata" cheese is made with Fior di latte cows milk cultures. We then fill our Burrata with fresh Stracciatella cream. This is often served with...