Condiments

Sweet Ella's Organic Crunch Peanut Butter

If you're an organic, crunchy peanut butter lover, you can't go wrong with Sweet Ella's 100% organic! Wholesome with exceptional flavor describes this fabulous nut butter. Try a jar today!

Mikes Mustard Dill

This Sweet Creamy Lemon Dill Mustard is a tangy delight! Try it as a dip, on a sandwich or your favorite meat or fish. It all adds up to a really tasty flavor that will surprise your taste buds. Made in Charlevoix.

Mikes Mustard BBQ

Mike's Sweet Creamy BBQ Mustard is our 5th and newest flavor!  The mustard that can do a lot! Great for grilling, as a dip for chicken, on pork, salmon, a hamburger, turkey burger or veggie burger. Add to baked beans to spice up the flavor.

Cherry Poppyseed Dressing

The Traverse Bay Farms Cherry Poppyseed Salad Dressing is full of great cherry and poppyseed taste. Enjoy over your favorite salad and as a dip for fresh fruit including freshly cut apples, pears and more.

Lavender Infused Syrup

Culinary lavender gives this syrup a freshness you’ll sense in both your mouth and nose.

Mikes Mustard Regular

Mike’s Original Sweet Creamy Mustard is THE original flavor. This sweet creamy mustard will drive your taste buds happy. Brush on and serve with your favorite meat or sandwich for a stunning new flavor. Use as a dip for pretzels or fresh vegetables. Your...

Blueberry Balsamic Vinaigrette

The Traverse Bay Farms Blueberry Balsamic Vinaigrette Salad Dressing is full of great blueberry and vinaigrette flavor. In addition, to enjoying with any salad, you can also use this tasty vinaigrette dressing as a dip for bread or drizzle over...

Mikes Mustard Jalapeno

Mike’s Sweet Creamy Jalapeno Mustard is Dave's Favorite. Smoke your taste buds with our outstanding sweet Jalapeno Mustard. Try it on a brat or beef, mix it with cream cheese, or use it as a dip for pretzels. There are tons of ways to enjoy our unique...

Mikes Mustard Cherry

This Sweet Creamy Cherry Mustard is amazingly unique. Use as a dip, on a sandwich, your favorite meat or add a bit to spice up chicken salad. Serve it on a brat or brush it on salmon. Made in Charlevoix.

Saffron & Apricot Infused Syrup

Tangy apricots and floral saffron create a luxurious blend of flavors in this infusion.

Whole Seed Mustard

This sophisticated mustard features whole yellow and black mustard seeds soaked in vinegar and Michigan sparkling wine. The seeds become plump, tender and toothsome as they’re infused with the wine’s complexity and then burst with every taste, releasing...

Horseradish Maple Mustard

This peppy blend of sweet caramelly maple and spicy horseradish adds a spicy kick to sandwiches and dressings. Spread over artisan cheeses or a warm pretzel. Try it as a glaze on roast pork, roast beef, and on roasted root vegetables.

Chardonnay Maple Mustard

The perfect balance of savory and sweet.

Bourbon Barrel Infused Syrup

We age our pure maple syrup in bourbon barrels from Grand Traverse Distillery, and the result is exquisite.

Maple Syrup by Maple Moon

Pure Michigan Maple Syrup is delicious on pancakes, waffles, french toast, hot and cold cereals, ice cream, yogurt and fruit...a a glaze for ham and vegetables...in baked beans and in place of sugar in baking. If any harmless mold farms, heat syrup and...

Maple Syrup Maple Moon Jug

Pure Michigan Maple Syrup is delicious on pancakes, waffles, french toast, hot and cold cereals, ice cream, yogurt and fruit...a a glaze for ham and vegetables...in baked beans and in place of sugar in baking. If any harmless mold farms, heat syrup and...

Hot and Smoky BBQ Sauce

This BBQ sauces is NO-NO-NO! No corn syrup, No corn starch, and No artificial coloring, No GMO! We’ve turned up the heat factor on this sauce and paired it with some hickory smoke flavor. Locally made near Traverse City.

Sicilian Lemon Balsamic

Our Sicilian lemon balsamic (white) has bright and sweet notes without the bitter and sour flavors characteristic of most lemon varieties. An all around staple in the Mediterranian diet, our Sicilian Lemon balsamic will surely give a fresh lemon kick to...

Garlic Olive Oil

This Garlic olive oil is a perfect example of adding robust garlic flavor through an olive oil wherever garlic is required. Imagine of smelling the aroma of a freshly peeled garlic clove diced into small pieces. Garlic olive oil is the essential...

Smoky Backyard BBQ Sauce

A bold, smoky, and deeply complex take on classic tomato-based barbecue sauce (think Kansas City-style). This thick sauce is the perfect companion to ribs and robust grilled meats, and it’s just as delicious on poultry.

Basil Crush Olive Oil

Fustini's Basil olive oil is produced by crushing the olives and basil simultaneously in the same press. This process allows for the essential oils from the basil to harmonize with the oil from Coratina olives.

18 yr. Balsamic

Traditional 18 year style dark balsamic is a world-class balsamic with the perfect balance and structure of sweet and sour, notes of prune and caramel with a creamy texture that extends into a long finish.

Traverse City Cherry Balsamic

Sweet and tart with local cherry puree from Traverse City, Michigan. This Fustini's EXCLUSIVE vinegar is ideal for a deliciously well-balanced vinegrette, to cook with leafy greens, as a marinade or reduced to a glaze to finish off your favorite dishes.

Apples Peaches Pumpkin Pie

Apples & Peaches with a touch of Pumpkin Pie Spice. Tastes like Fall in a jar! Great swirled into a muffin before baking.  Add a dollop to a baked sweet potato.

Sriracha

Five different peppers sweetened to perfection with pure maple syrup.

Just Peachy

Tastes like a fresh juicy peach! Great on top of a brick of cream cheese for a quick appetizer.

Cherry Cherry Bang Bang

Our newest flavor!  Made with locally grown Cherry Bomb Peppers and Habanero Peppers.

Christmas Cranberry

This holiday jam is perfect as a side for Thanksgiving Day Dinner and Holiday Entertaining. Makes a great hostess gift! Delicious throughout the whole year.

Peppy Peach

If you like a bit of heat, then this jam is for you. Makes a great appetizer: pour over a brick of cream cheese or goat cheese and serve with fancy crackers. Easy!!!