google-site-verification=SOd04LCcWqgQSZOlyjWZO6bt6ZxnDjlpsdzNbM4fuuo

Condiments

Please Note: If your order contains frozen, refrigerated, or physically large items, that we do not ship them and your ENTIRE order will be available for curbside pickup only. Thank You.

  • Red Raspberry Preserves

    Red Raspberry Preserves

    This classic Red Raspberry Preserves captures the rich, bright color and delightful sweet-tartness of these plump, velvety berries. Their flavor intensifies as they cook down in the American Spoon copper kettles, creating a preserve that fans of fresh...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Sweet Ella's Organic Smooth Peanut Butter

    Sweet Ella's Organic Smooth Peanut Butter

    Sweet Ella's Organic Smooth Peanut Butter is named after the owner's daughter. Made with Spanish peanuts, this peanut butter has an exceptionally sweet flavor profile. Just two ingredients: Organic Peanuts and Sea Salt. One taste and we are sure you will...
    $8.45
    Add to Cart
  • Day Off Drink Mix

    Day Off Drink Mix

    Made with fresh jalapenos and Michigan cherry juice, this mix is the perfect blend of sweet, tart and spicy. Mix with tequila to make the perfect margarita or mix with a light beer for a Beer-Rita or a Sparkling Wine for a spicy Cherry Mimosa. Imagine...
    $4.99
    Choose Options
  • DD214 Hot Sauce

    DD214 Hot Sauce

    This sauce tastes like freedom. DD214 is a Serrano/habanero and dill sauce. Think of this as a spicy dill pickle only more AMAZING!  DD214 is the discharge form issued from the military. This sauce is our nod to the veteran community and the taste of...
    $9.99
    Add to Cart
  • Castaway Hot Sauce

    Castaway Hot Sauce

    Habanero Citrus Herb Hot Sauce. Awesome on shrimp and fish! Also great on chicken and tofu! Another favorite is mixing it in quinoa or rice as a spicy side. Note: Product will separate, shakewell before using. Ingredients: Vinegar, Pineapple Juice,...
    $9.99
    Add to Cart
  • Cherry BBQ Sauce

    Cherry BBQ Sauce

    This sauce adds BBQ flair and flavor to chicken, pork, beef and a hearty fish like salmon. Also great as a dip or marinade, mix into meatloaf or a burger, add to baked beans, spread on pizza, a sandwich or wrap.
    $8.50
    Add to Cart
  • Wildflower Honey Mustard

    Wildflower Honey Mustard

    A classic midwestern condiment made with fragrant Northern Michigan hoeny. Thick, creamy, and rich this mustard is perfect for hot dogs, pretzels and sandwiches.
    $11.95
    Add to Cart
  • Pumpkin Butter

    Pumpkin Butter

    Like pumpkin pie in a jar! We slow cook pumpkin with fall spices and lightly sweeten with maple and brown sugar to make this traditional favorite. Spoon over pancakes, spread on graham crackers, or fold into waffle batter for a quintessential fall...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Apple & Onion Jam

    Apple & Onion Jam

    This sweet and savory jam features chunks of sweet Michigan Northern Spy apples and deeply caramelized onions scented with thyme and balsamic vinegar. It's the perfect foil for the robust flavors of beef and pork, but it's also just as delicious with...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Heirloom Blueberry Preserves

    Heirloom Blueberry Preserves

    This classic Midwestern preserve is thick with small Rubel Blueberries grown for American Spoon along the Lake Michigan shore on several Southwest Michigan family farms. Rubels are smaller-than-average blueberries with a deep, jammy flavor and a hint of...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Cherry Gorgonzola Salad Dressing

    Cherry Gorgonzola Salad Dressing

    Creamy Gorgonzola cheese mixes with juicy bits of Northern Michigan cherries and ground black pepper to create this gourmet-style salad dressing. Use it to dress up your favorite green salad or use as a pre-grilling marinade for beef.
    $9.95
    Add to Cart
  • Great Hall Cherry Vinaigrette

    Great Hall Cherry Vinaigrette

    This slightly sweet, creamy-style vinaigrette features bold garlic flavor that perfectly accentuates a blend of sweet and tart cherries from Northern Michigan. Drizzle over a crisp green salad and pair with a chilled glass of rosé for a cool summer...
    $9.95
    Add to Cart
  • Dressing Roasted Garlic

    Dressing Roasted Garlic

    Use this versatile dressing on your favorite salad, or as a marinade and grilling sauce with beef, pork, poultry and seafood. Locally made near Traverse City
    $8.35
    Add to Cart
  • Maple Syrup

    Maple Syrup

    With its smooth depth of maple flavor, Amber maple syrup is the best grade for all-around use in the kitchen and on the table.
    $14.95
    Choose Options
  • Blueberry Spoon Fruit Sugar Free

    Blueberry Spoon Fruit Sugar Free

    One of the oldest domesticated varieties, the Rubel Blueberry is a tiny dark-blue berry adapted from the wild. They heighten the flavor of these small gems with intensely concentrated wild blueberry juice to create their Blueberry Spoon Fruit, the...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Dressing Blueberry Lavender

    Dressing Blueberry Lavender

    Based on an award-winning Blueberry Lavender Preserves, this sweet and tangy dressing is enhanced with just the right amount of lavender. Perfect on a salad of spinach, fresh berries, red onion and feta; toss with fresh fruit; glaze poultry or pork...
    $8.35
    Add to Cart
  • Ginger Root Infused Syrup

    Ginger Root Infused Syrup

    Ginger Infused Maple SyrupWe infuse our Amber Rich pure maple syrup with the complex flavor of ginger. The taste sensation starts off with sweet caramel and finishes with lemony, warm, peppery ginger. This infusion can be used in both sweet and savory...
    $15.95
    Add to Cart
  • Sour Cherry Spoon Fruit Sugar Free

    Sour Cherry Spoon Fruit Sugar Free

    Tart Michigan Montmorencies are most commonly baked into pie, but true devotees eat them out-of-hand at market stands throughout Northern Michigan. American Spoon Sour Cherry Spoon Fruit celebrates the vibrant tartness of Michigan's most famous fruit in...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Apple and Cinnamon Preserves

    Apple and Cinnamon Preserves

    Inspired by the classic comfort of warm apple pie, this preserve features chunks of apples grown in Charlevoix, Michigan, lots of cinnamon, and a hint of vanilla for a deeply layered take on a favorite and familiar flavor. Swirl it into oatmeal, spread...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Dressing Vinaigrette Cherry Poppy

    Dressing Vinaigrette Cherry Poppy

    A delicious and versatile dressing, this Cherry Poppy Seed Vinaigrette is perfect on salads and also makes an amazing marinade for chicken and pork. Toss fresh greens, with feta, goat or blue  cheese, add dried cherries and toasted pine nuts or almonds...
    $8.35
    Add to Cart
  • Strawberry Rhubarb Preserves

    Strawberry Rhubarb Preserves

    Early Glow Strawberries come into season just before the delightfully tart rhubarb of Spring begins to fade from Michigan fields. This timeless marriage of the first warm-weather harvests is simply irresistible.
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Strawberry Poppyseed Dressing

    Strawberry Poppyseed Dressing

    A rich tasting salad dressing! The Traverse Bay Farms Strawberry Salad Dressing is a great addition to your favorite salad. You'll also enjoy as a dip for fresh fruit including freshly cut apples, pears and more.
    $8.65
    Add to Cart
  • Mikes Mustard BBQ

    Mikes Mustard BBQ

    Mike's Sweet Creamy BBQ Mustard is our 5th and newest flavor!  The mustard that can do a lot! Great for grilling, as a dip for chicken, on pork, salmon, a hamburger, turkey burger or veggie burger. Add to baked beans to spice up the flavor.
    $11.75
    Choose Options
  • Sour Cherry Preserves

    Sour Cherry Preserves

    Loaded with Montmorency Cherries, Michigan's most famous fruit. With its deep red color and brightly tart flavor, this perennial Fruitlands favorite has distinguished itself as the finest example of Michigan's most beloved preserve.
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Cherry Poppyseed Dressing

    Cherry Poppyseed Dressing

    The Traverse Bay Farms Cherry Poppyseed Salad Dressing is full of great cherry and poppyseed taste. Enjoy over your favorite salad and as a dip for fresh fruit including freshly cut apples, pears and more.
    $8.65
    Add to Cart
  • Mikes Mustard Regular

    Mikes Mustard Regular

    Mike’s Original Sweet Creamy Mustard is THE original flavor. This sweet creamy mustard will drive your taste buds happy. Brush on and serve with your favorite meat or sandwich for a stunning new flavor. Use as a dip for pretzels or fresh vegetables. Your...
    $11.75
    Choose Options
  • Early Glow Strawberry Preserves

    Early Glow Strawberry Preserves

    Few varieties are as difficult to grow as the Early Glow, but no other berry delivers such intense strawberry flavor. The berries for this American Spoon award-winning Early Glow Strawberry Preserves have been sourced from the Bardenhagen centennial...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Blueberry Balsamic Vinaigrette

    Blueberry Balsamic Vinaigrette

    The Traverse Bay Farms Blueberry Balsamic Vinaigrette Salad Dressing is full of great blueberry and vinaigrette flavor. In addition, to enjoying with any salad, you can also use this tasty vinaigrette dressing as a dip for bread or drizzle over...
    $8.65
    Add to Cart
  • Mikes Mustard Jalapeno

    Mikes Mustard Jalapeno

    Mike’s Sweet Creamy Jalapeno Mustard is Dave's Favorite. Smoke your taste buds with our outstanding sweet Jalapeno Mustard. Try it on a brat or beef, mix it with cream cheese, or use it as a dip for pretzels. There are tons of ways to enjoy our unique...
    $11.75
    Choose Options
  • Red Haven Peach Preserves

    Red Haven Peach Preserves

    From Joe Daly's orchards along the shores of Lake Michigan, the luscious Red Haven peach produces the ultimate chunky peach preserve. American Spoon is one of the last companies in America that still hand peels and hand pits this melting flesh variety of...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Whole Seed Mustard

    Whole Seed Mustard

    This sophisticated mustard features whole yellow and black mustard seeds soaked in vinegar and Michigan sparkling wine. The seeds become plump, tender and toothsome as they’re infused with the wine’s complexity and then burst with every taste, releasing...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Damson Plum Preserves

    Damson Plum Preserves

    Spoon is devoted to this ancient but increasingly overlooked variety of tiny purple plum, an enduring favorite for culinary use. Damsons are too sour and bitter for fresh eating, but when sweetened judiciously with cane sugar and cooked down in our...
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Horseradish Maple Mustard

    Horseradish Maple Mustard

    This peppy blend of sweet caramelly maple and spicy horseradish adds a spicy kick to sandwiches and dressings. Spread over artisan cheeses or a warm pretzel. Try it as a glaze on roast pork, roast beef, and on roasted root vegetables.
    $12.95
    Add to Cart
  • Leelanau Apricot Preserves

    Leelanau Apricot Preserves

    A beloved favorite is back in stock! The Spoon Leelanau Apricots are all grown on the Jelinek Farm near Leland, where the trees are protected by breezes off Lake Michigan. The American Spoon crew hand-pit these gorgeous, red-cheeked apricots to create...
    $13.95
    Add to Cart
  • Bartlett Pear Preserves

    Bartlett Pear Preserves

    Thick with hand-cut chunks of golden Bartlett pears, these preserves are luscious served with pancakes or with hard and soft cheeses. A favorite of those who love the lingering, mellow, low acid sweetness of soft, ripe pears.
    $12.95
    Add to Cart