Condiments

Spicy Cherry BBQ Sauce

For citizens who love a slight spicy kick, the Spicy Cherry Barbecue Sauce will make your mouth tingle and your lips smile. Our top-secret blend of spices and cherries makes our Cherry Barbecue Sauce rich, tangy, and wonderfully different. Spread some...

Mikes Mustard Jalapeno

Mike’s Sweet Creamy Jalapeno Mustard is Dave's Favorite. Smoke your taste buds with our outstanding sweet Jalapeno Mustard. Try it on a brat or beef, mix it with cream cheese, or use it as a dip for pretzels. There are tons of ways to enjoy our unique...

Great Hall Cherry Vinaigrette

This slightly sweet, creamy-style vinaigrette features bold garlic flavor that perfectly accentuates a blend of sweet and tart cherries from Northern Michigan. Drizzle over a crisp green salad and pair with a chilled glass of rosé for a cool summer...

Horseradish Maple Mustard

This peppy blend of sweet caramelly maple and spicy horseradish adds a spicy kick to sandwiches and dressings. Spread over artisan cheeses or a warm pretzel. Try it as a glaze on roast pork, roast beef, and on roasted root vegetables.

Chardonnay Maple Mustard

The perfect balance of savory and sweet.

Wildflower Honey Mustard

A classic midwestern condiment made with fragrant Northern Michigan hoeny. Thick, creamy, and rich this mustard is perfect for hot dogs, pretzels and sandwiches.

Pumpkin Chipotle Roasting Sauce

A fall favorite! Incorporating the wonderful flavors of autumn, this rich and complex sauce of pumpkin, apple cider, chipotle peppers, brown sugar, and spices is great on pork, poultry, and other root vegetables.

Smoky Backyard BBQ Sauce

A bold, smoky, and deeply complex take on classic tomato-based barbecue sauce (think Kansas City-style). This thick sauce is the perfect companion to ribs and robust grilled meats, and it’s just as delicious on poultry.

Dressing Roasted Garlic

Use this versatile dressing on your favorite salad, or as a marinade and grilling sauce with beef, pork, poultry and seafood. Locally made near Traverse City

Greek Goddess Dressing

Bursting with color and flavor, this Creamy Pink Greek dressing will excite your taste buds with velvety smooth Greek flavors.

Sesame Ginger Vinegrette

A vibrant Asian style dressing with the rich flavors of ginger and sesame from expeller pressed toasted sesame oil. Great as a salmon marinade, dipping sauce and dressing for any Asian dish or salad.

Signature BBQ Sauce

This sweet and spicy barbecue sauce is the perfect blend of tangy ketchup and zesty vinegar, with a hint of heat that will tantalize your taste buds. The sweetness comes from a carefully balanced combination of brown sugar and molasses, while the...

Apple Bourbon BBQ Sauce

Everything goes better with famous, New Holland Beer Barrel Bourbon®! A little spicy, a little sweet, with tender bits of Michigan apples to give distinctive flavor and satisfying texture to anything from wings to pulled pork. Subtly enhanced with a...

Southwest Vinaigrette Dressing

A zesty dressing made with tangy flavors including cumin, organic apple cider vinegar & organic lemon juice. Cumin has a unique flavor that is widely used in Mexican, Cuban, Mediterranean & Indian cuisine! This dressing is great on a taco salad,...

Horseradish

Wholesome roots harvested at the very peak of flavor, the result is a bold but refined natural flavor. Specially certified product for Passover is available. Keep refrigerated.

Cherry BBQ Sauce

This sauce adds BBQ flair and flavor to chicken, pork, beef and a hearty fish like salmon. Also great as a dip or marinade, mix into meatloaf or a burger, add to baked beans, spread on pizza, a sandwich or wrap.

Vegan Caesar Dressing

Fresh ingredients will make these your first go-to choice for a snack when you hit an afternoon slump or want a little something sweet after your meal.

Mediterranean Lemon Dressing & Marinade

A fresh, light authentic Mediterranean dressing with bold flavor! Pairs well with any salad including Greek salad and is a wonderful fattoush & tabouli dressing. We love this dressing drizzled on avocado toast with micro greens.  It's very versatile...

Balsamic Fig Vinaigrette Dressing

A new twist on a classic! If you like balsamic vinegar, you'll love our balsamic fig dressing! It's smooth & balanced and gets its light sweetness using organic orange juice, California figs, and a touch of honey. 

Cherry BBQ Sauce by American Spoon

Brush dazzlingly sophisticated cherry flavor over pork tenderloin, grilled duck or chicken breast, roasted leg of lamb, or even grilled brats.

Sicilian Lemon Balsamic

Our Sicilian lemon balsamic (white) has bright and sweet notes without the bitter and sour flavors characteristic of most lemon varieties. An all around staple in the Mediterranian diet, our Sicilian Lemon balsamic will surely give a fresh lemon kick to...

Garlic Olive Oil

This Garlic olive oil is a perfect example of adding robust garlic flavor through an olive oil wherever garlic is required. Imagine of smelling the aroma of a freshly peeled garlic clove diced into small pieces. Garlic olive oil is the essential...

Basil Crush Olive Oil

Fustini's Basil olive oil is produced by crushing the olives and basil simultaneously in the same press. This process allows for the essential oils from the basil to harmonize with the oil from Coratina olives.

18 yr. Balsamic

Traditional 18 year style dark balsamic is a world-class balsamic with the perfect balance and structure of sweet and sour, notes of prune and caramel with a creamy texture that extends into a long finish.

Traverse City Cherry Balsamic

Sweet and tart with local cherry puree from Traverse City, Michigan. This Fustini's EXCLUSIVE vinegar is ideal for a deliciously well-balanced vinegrette, to cook with leafy greens, as a marinade or reduced to a glaze to finish off your favorite dishes.

Mikes Mustard Dill

This Sweet Creamy Lemon Dill Mustard is a tangy delight! Try it as a dip, on a sandwich or your favorite meat or fish. It all adds up to a really tasty flavor that will surprise your taste buds. Made in Charlevoix.

Mabs’ BBQ Sauce and Marinade

We use only premium, fine ground mustard flour and pure cane sugar to ensure the best and most consistent taste possible. Its explosive flavor is delicious on sandwiches, crunchy snacks, or in your favorite sauces.

Mabs’ Atomic Mustard

An "easy to handle" bottle for sandwiches, burgers, and everything else! 13 oz Squeeze Bottle

Sweet and Sassy BBQ Sauce

This sauce adds BBQ flair and flavor to chicken, pork, beef and a hearty fish like salmon. Also great as a dip or marinade, mix into meatloaf or a burger, add to baked beans, spread on pizza, a sandwich or wrap. These BBQ sauces are NO-NO-NO! NO corn...

Mikes Mustard BBQ

Mike's Sweet Creamy BBQ Mustard is our 5th and newest flavor!  The mustard that can do a lot! Great for grilling, as a dip for chicken, on pork, salmon, a hamburger, turkey burger or veggie burger. Add to baked beans to spice up the flavor.

Hot and Smoky BBQ Sauce

This BBQ sauces is NO-NO-NO! No corn syrup, No corn starch, and No artificial coloring, No GMO! We’ve turned up the heat factor on this sauce and paired it with some hickory smoke flavor. Locally made near Traverse City.

Dressing Blueberry Lavender

Based on an award-winning Blueberry Lavender Preserves, this sweet and tangy dressing is enhanced with just the right amount of lavender. Perfect on a salad of spinach, fresh berries, red onion and feta; toss with fresh fruit; glaze poultry or pork...

Dressing Maple Cream Mustard

Sweet and tangy dressing made with real Michigan maple syrup and Food for Thought signature Maple Cream Mustard. Locally made near Traverse City

Dressing Vinaigrette Cherry Poppy

A delicious and versatile dressing, this Cherry Poppy Seed Vinaigrette is perfect on salads and also makes an amazing marinade for chicken and pork. Toss fresh greens, with feta, goat or blue  cheese, add dried cherries and toasted pine nuts or almonds...

Whole Seed Mustard

This sophisticated mustard features whole yellow and black mustard seeds soaked in vinegar and Michigan sparkling wine. The seeds become plump, tender and toothsome as they’re infused with the wine’s complexity and then burst with every taste, releasing...

Mikes Mustard Regular

Mike’s Original Sweet Creamy Mustard is THE original flavor. This sweet creamy mustard will drive your taste buds happy. Brush on and serve with your favorite meat or sandwich for a stunning new flavor. Use as a dip for pretzels or fresh vegetables. Your...

Cherry Poppyseed Dressing

The Traverse Bay Farms Cherry Poppyseed Salad Dressing is full of great cherry and poppyseed taste. Enjoy over your favorite salad and as a dip for fresh fruit including freshly cut apples, pears and more.

Maple Balsamic Vinaigrette

A favorite at the Harwood Gold Cafe, this vinaigrette combines white balsamic vinegar with our Chardonnay Maple Mustard.

Ketchup

Small batch, old-fashioned catsup, sweetened only with Harwood Gold pure maple syrup.

BBQ Sauce

A small-batch barbecue sauce sweetened with pure maple syrup. Chipotle peppers give it smokiness and a sweet, smoky zing.

Mikes Mustard Cherry

This Sweet Creamy Cherry Mustard is amazingly unique. Use as a dip, on a sandwich, your favorite meat or add a bit to spice up chicken salad. Serve it on a brat or brush it on salmon. Made in Charlevoix.