Cheese

Fresh Mozzarella Ball

Fresh Mozzarella Pearls

Seahive Cheddar

Seahive is a true expression of the flavors of Utah. Sweet and creamy, the rind of this Utah cheddar is rubbed with  wildflower honey and ancient salt. Yes, ancient salt. The salt is harvested from a pristine ocean deposit in Redmond, Utah. This gives...

Cheddar Gruyere Herbs de Provence Cheese

Cheddar Gruyere cheese enriched with the savory mixture of aromatic Mediterranean herbs . Best of Class winner at the 2014 World Championship Cheese Contest and 2nd Place at the 2014 American Cheese Society Contest. Pairs well with Gruner Veltliner wine...

Cheddar Gruyere Original Cheese

A unique fusion of Cheddar and Gruyere that is classic, creamy and aged to perfection. This Cheddar Gruyere semi-hard cheese is made in limited quantities and aged to develop  sweet and nutty notes.

Cheddar Gruyere Cracked Peppercorn Cheese

Cheddar Gruyere cheese enhanced with roasted red peppers and cracked peppercorn offers a pleasant sweetness that is contrasted nicely with a punch of savory spice from cracked black peppercorn. Pairs well with Merlot, Pilsner or Pale Ale. Look for this...

Toma Truffle Cheese Wedge

TomaTruffle is the perfect combination of classic Toma paired with the aromatic flavors of Italian Black Truffles from Umbria. Reminiscent of undergrowth, fresh strawberries, dried fruit and a hint of cocoa, the earthy flavor marries beautifully with the...

Toma Cheese Wedge

In Italian, Toma means “wheel of cheese made by the farmer herself.” What better way to describe this, a versatile, any time, any table cheese. All natural, pasteurized, semi-hard table cheese with a waxed rind. Made from pasteurized, rBST-free cows’...

Original Blue Cheese Wedge

Produced on a family farm since 2000, California’s classic style blue cheese is rindless, all-natural and gluten-free. The addictive flavor is bold with hints of sweet milk and a peppery finish. Made from raw (non-pasteurized), rBST-free cows’ milk Made...

Bay Blue Cheese Wedge

Bay Blue is a rustic-style blue cheese with a natural rind. It is known for its mellow flavor and sweet, salted caramel finish. Made from pasteurized, rBST-free cows’ milk Made with traditional rennet Gluten-free Aged for 90 days

Premium 1 Year Gouda

A firm and crystalized texture make this true farmstead Gouda sweetly aged. Complex notes of toasted nuts finish out the profiles of this lively cheese. All Marieke® Gouda is made using fresh raw milk from our family farm. We handcraft each wheel with...

Holy Trinity Melange Gouda

An aromatic flavor base similar to mirepoix that swaps out the carrot for the sweeter, more mellow green bell pepper. All Marieke® Gouda is made using fresh raw milk from our family farm. We handcraft each wheel with the finest Old World techniques and...

Golden Gouda

This American Original precisely encapsulates the American dream. A combination of Parmesan and Gouda has a freshness unrivaled, and with a buttery texture and a pleasantly sweet aroma, you can't go wrong. All Marieke® Gouda is made using fresh raw milk...

Raclette Wedge

Leelanau Raclette is a semi-soft washed-rind cheese with a distinct nutty and buttery flavor. Aged for 2-4 months.  We use single-source cow's milk farmed in Northwest Michigan.  The specialty at Leelanau Cheese, based on a 25 year tradition, first...

Spreadable Honey Lavender Goat Cheese

Idyll Pastures spreadable is named after the wild grasses and flowers growing on the Great Lakes Pastures that our Certified Humane® Alpine goats graze on at Idyll Farms. The resulting fresh farmstead goat cheese is fluffy, creamy, and totally smearable...

Spreadable Garlic Goat Cheese

A fresh, rindless, spreadable goat cheese from Idyll Farms in northern MI, made from the pasteurized milk of the farm’s goats. Fluffy, creamy and versatile, this spreadable cheese has citrusy, tangy flavor with savory notes of garlic.

Morel and Leek Jack Cheese

A Michigan Jack cheese with morel mushroom and leek.  This seasonal cheese is bursting with a nutty earthy flavor with a hint of sweet onion.

Feta Crumbles

Dodoni Crumbled Feta Cheese. Dodoni is the best-selling brand in Greece using milk from the Epirus region of Greece and recognized for its top quality, distinctive flavor and texture.

Charlevoix Monterey Jack Cheese

Delightfully smooth and creamy, our monterey jack cheese promises an indulgent buttery taste that captures the essence of artisanal cheesemaking, inviting you to savor every bite.

Charlevoix Cheese Curds

Our freshly made cheese curds offer an irresistible combination of soft, milky freshness with the perfect ratio of salt to cheese, promising a flavorful and inviting snacking experience.

Charlevoix Quark Cheese

Creamy and versatile, quark cheese is a fresh spreadable cheese, perfect for topping toast, bagels, or on crackers. 

Charlevoix Cheddar Cheese

Savor the creamy, richness of our farmstead mild cheddar; crafted with care, its delightful flavor and smooth texture is perfect for every occasion from snacking to culinary creations.

Creamy Briette: Blue or Mild

Creamy & Blue is soft and creamy with just a hint of blue culture for a truly beginner blue experience.  Creamy & Mild is smooth and has a sweet and rich milk taste.

Parmigiano Reggiano Wedge EW

Rich in nutrients, Parmigiano Reggiano is a cheese rich in protein, vitamins and minerals. Extremely good, highly digestable and absolutely natural, it is recommended in all diets. Perfect for quick and easy recipes, from starters to appetizers that can...

Ricotta Hand Dipped 1.5lb

Liuzzi's ricotta is a creamy, large style curd with a delicate sweet flavor. It is hand-dipped, Fina style, which is smooth and creamy with a sweet milky flavor.

Purple Haze Goat Cheese

Subtly sweet with the tangy brightness of fresh goat cheese! The distinct and unexpected marriage of lavender and hand-harvested fennel pollen makes Purple Haze utterly addictive — and unforgettable. They use the finest ingredients they can get our...

Classic Mini Brie

Small format single cream brie, very rich and buttery.

Cervelle de Canut

Winner of 2022 American Cheese Society award! French-inspired fresh goat cheese spread with shallots, chives, pepper and vinegar.

Green Thunder Cheddar 7oz Wheel

Balancing rich roasted garlic with aromatic garden herbs, Green Thunder creates a singularly delicious savoury experience. Fresh, smooth and creamy, it's a delightful addition to any cheeseboard and pairs excellently with a dry sparkling wine or a light...

Black Bomber Cheddar 7oz Wheel

The award-winning Black Bomber is a modern classic. Marrying a delicious rich flavor with a smooth creaminess, our flagship cheddar cheese lasts long on the palate remains demandingly moreish. Black Bommer has won awards at The British Cheese Awards,...

Cave Aged Cheddar

This cave-aged Cheddar variety has a creamy color and distinctive rind  that develops in the open-air cave, where natural mold flourish and add beautiful character to the cheese. Sid says its earthy flavor is reminiscent of the cheese his family made...

Menage Cheese

This mixed-milk beauty is aged for intense flavor and a drier texture. It's dipped in a lovely wax as vibrant and green as Wisconsin's summertime pastures.

Apple Smoked Cheddar

This white cheddar is apple smoked then hand rubbed with paprika. It has a slightly smoky flavor that balances very well with the paprika.

Cheese Cheddar Yellow Extra Sharp

This extra sharp cheddar is matured a minimum of 18 months. 8 ounces. Please Note: If your order contains frozen, refrigerated, or physically large items, that we do not ship them and your ENTIRE order will be available for curbside pickup only. Thank...

Cheese Colby

Colby, similar to Cheddar, does not undergo the cheddaring process. This soft, moist and fairly mild Colby is excellent as a table cheese, perfect for grating and grilling, and in snacks and salads. 8 ounces. Please Note: If your order contains frozen,...

Cheese Cheddar White Medium

This Medium White Cheddar is matured for a minimum of 6 months. 8 ounces. Please Note: If your order contains frozen, refrigerated, or physically large items, that we do not ship them and your ENTIRE order will be available for curbside pickup only...

Cheese Cheddar White Sharp

This Sharp White Cheddar is matured for a minimum of 12 months. 8 ounces. Please Note: If your order contains frozen, refrigerated, or physically large items, that we do not ship them and your ENTIRE order will be available for curbside pickup only...

Cheese Smoky Jack

This is not a smoked cheese, but rather a creamy Jack cheese combined with 11 different spices to give it a “just off the grill” flavor. Created for an old friend and grilling aficionado; he has given it his stamp of burger approval. We are...

Cheese Jack Michigan

This young Jack cheese is a deliciously mild cheese. Its creamy texture, high moisture and mild flavor make it easy to pair with fruits and a delicious compliment to any sandwich or burger. 8 ounces. Please Note: If your order contains frozen,...

Cheese Dill

We cannot think of many combinations more perfect than dill and this supple Jack cheese. The creamy mild Jack has a slight buttery aroma and is given a subtle pop of flavor by the addition of fresh farm grown dill. This sweet and mellow cheese matches...