Online Store Now Open!

Shop & Pay online | We call when your order is ready | Pick up at the Market!


  • Cheese Curds

    Cheese Curds

    The Farmer's Creamery is Michigan's new favorite Dairy and Farm destination. Owned and operated by local Amish in the Mio area, they offer a full range of dairy items from 100% grass-fed cows, without antibiotics and no added hormones.
    Choose Options
  • Basil Garlic Colby Cheese

    Basil Garlic Colby Cheese

    From a small Amish farm in Clare Michigan. Natural Way Cheese creates their artisan cheeses using a low-heat vat pastuerization, which takes longer, but results in a more flavorful cheese that retains beneficial enzymes while still killing off anything...
    Add to Cart
  • Green Thunder Cheddar 7oz Wheel

    Green Thunder Cheddar 7oz Wheel

    Balancing rich roasted garlic with aromatic garden herbs, Green Thunder creates a singularly delicious savoury experience. Fresh, smooth and creamy, it's a delightful addition to any cheeseboard and pairs excellently with a dry sparkling wine or a light...
    Add to Cart
  • Black Bommer Cheddar 7oz Wheel

    Black Bommer Cheddar 7oz Wheel

    The award-winning Black Bommer is a modern classic. Marrying a delicious rich flavor with a smooth creaminess, our flagship cheddar cheese lasts long on the palate remains demandingly moreish. Black Bommer has won awards at The British Cheese Awards,...
    Add to Cart
  • Amber Mist Whiskey Cheddar 7oz Wheel

    Amber Mist Whiskey Cheddar 7oz Wheel

    The rich, warming notes of Scotch whiskey combine with mouthwatering mature cheddar to create an indulgent, grown-up pairing. Enjoying it with a dram at the end of the day. Amber Mist is Nantwich International Cheese Awards gold winner.
    Add to Cart
  • White Cheddar with Chipotle

    White Cheddar with Chipotle

    Sincerely, Brigitte Chipotle Cheddar Cheese, 7 oz Wisconsin Cheese What happens when you live, breathe, and dream about cheese and want to share your passion with everyone around? Sincerely, Brigitte™ is my creation, an explosion of flavor in every bite...
    Add to Cart
  • Menage Cheese

    Menage Cheese

    This mixed-milk beauty is aged for intense flavor and a drier texture. It's dipped in a lovely wax as vibrant and green as Wisconsin's summertime pastures.
    Add to Cart
  • Vlaskaas Precut Cheese

    Vlaskaas Precut Cheese

    Vlaskaas was historically made only once a year, during the flax harvest festival, but as festival traditions fell away, the recipe was buried. Thankfully, in 2004, a review of Beemster’s past cheeses led to its rediscovery. Vlaskaas was obviously too...
    Add to Cart
  • Sunday Blend Grated Parmesean

    Sunday Blend Grated Parmesean

    100% freshly created cheese. All natural. A premium blend of Parmesean and locatelli Auricchio's Sunday Blend dates back to the early 1900's when a majority of Italian immigrants from Naples and Southern Italy came to the United States to begin new lives...
    Add to Cart
  • Parmigiano Reggiano Wedge EW

    Parmigiano Reggiano Wedge EW

    Rich in nutrients, Parmigiano Reggiano is a cheese rich in protein, vitamins and minerals. Extremely good, highly digestable and absolutely natural, it is recommended in all diets. Perfect for quick and easy recipes, from starters to appetizers that can...
    Add to Cart
  • Crema Di Locatelli

    Crema Di Locatelli

    All the flavor of Cacio e Pepe in a spreadable cream! Locatelli Crema Cacio e Pepe features high-quality Pecorino Romano, and it is perfect slathered on crackers and crusty bread, spread on sandwiches, or stirred into pasta and risotto. Its creamy and...
    Add to Cart
  • Cheese Colby

    Cheese Colby

    Colby, similar to Cheddar, does not undergo the cheddaring process. This soft, moist and fairly mild Colby is excellent as a table cheese, perfect for grating and grilling, and in snacks and salads. 8 ounces.
    Add to Cart
  • Cheese Marble

    Cheese Marble

    An outstanding mix of Colby and Michigan Jack cheeses. With wonderful color this cheese is terrific for cooking and is a delightful snacking cheese. 8 ounces.
    Add to Cart
  • Cheese Smoky Jack

    Cheese Smoky Jack

    This is not a smoked cheese, but rather a creamy Jack cheese combined with 11 different spices to give it a “just off the grill” flavor. Created for an old friend and grilling aficionado; he has given it his stamp of burger approval. We are sure you will...
    Add to Cart
  • Cheese Jack Michigan

    Cheese Jack Michigan

    This young Jack cheese is a deliciously mild cheese. Its creamy texture, high moisture and mild flavor make it easy to pair with fruits and a delicious compliment to any sandwich or burger. 8 ounces.
    Add to Cart
  • Cheese Dill

    Cheese Dill

    We cannot think of many combinations more perfect than dill and this supple Jack cheese. The creamy mild Jack has a slight buttery aroma and is given a subtle pop of flavor by the addition of fresh farm grown dill. This sweet and mellow cheese matches...
    Add to Cart